Domestic violence is a serious problem, and every allegation deserves to be taken seriously. It is also true that people are sometimes accused when the facts do not support the charge, whether because of a misunderstanding, an exaggeration, or an argument that turned into a police call. If that has happened to you, what you do next matters.
1. Do not contact the accuser. This is the step people most often get wrong. A no-contact order may already be in place, and even if it is not, reaching out to explain or apologize can be used against you or treated as intimidation. If the other person contacts you first, do not respond. Tell your lawyer.
2. Do not talk about the case. Statements to friends, family, coworkers, and on social media can be requested or reported. The only people you should discuss the facts with are your attorney and anyone your attorney directs.
3. Write down your account. Include dates, times, places, what was said, who else was present, and anything that happened before and after. Do this for your attorney only, and do it soon, while details are clear.
4. Save the evidence. Keep text messages, emails, voicemails, photos, social media messages, call logs, and receipts that show where you were. Do not delete anything, even if it looks bad. Deleted messages can create bigger problems later. Give copies to your attorney.
5. Identify witnesses. Neighbors, coworkers, friends, and anyone who saw or heard the incident or saw the people involved afterward can matter. Write down names and contact information.
6. Follow every court order exactly. If you were told to leave a home, stay away from a place, or surrender a license to carry, comply. Violating an order can lead to arrest and make the original case much harder to defend.
7. Understand how the case works. The prosecutor decides whether the charge goes forward, not the accuser. A case can move ahead even if the other person later says they want it dropped. Prosecutors review police reports, statements, photos, and 911 calls. What the evidence actually shows is what counts.
How a defense is built
A lawyer looks for inconsistencies in the accuser's statements, evidence that contradicts the account, signs of motive, whether the police report matches the facts, and whether there is evidence of self-defense. In some cases the question is whether the alleged conduct meets the legal definition of the offense at all.
Be ready for a long process
Domestic cases often involve a criminal case and a separate 209A restraining order hearing, and sometimes a family court matter. A coordinated approach is important.
Brian Roman has defended domestic violence charges in Attleboro, Taunton, Fall River, Dedham, and across Massachusetts. If you have been accused, contact (508) 687-6404 for a free and confidential consultation.