A notice for a clerk magistrate hearing can feel like a minor event. It is not. This hearing, sometimes called a show cause hearing, can decide whether a criminal charge is ever filed against you. Handled well, it can end the matter before it reaches your record.
What it is. Before some misdemeanors become formal criminal cases, a clerk magistrate or judge decides whether there is enough evidence to issue a criminal complaint. You receive a notice in the mail, often after a police report or a complaint from a store, a neighbor, or another person. Common examples include shoplifting, simple assault, harassment, threats, and motor vehicle offenses.
What the hearing is not
It is not a trial. No jury is present, and the question is not whether you are guilty. The magistrate decides only whether there is probable cause to believe a crime was committed and whether a complaint should issue.
What happens at the hearing
The hearing is usually informal and held in a small room, not a full courtroom. The police officer or the person who made the complaint explains what happened. You or your lawyer can respond, ask questions, and present your side, including documents or witnesses. The magistrate then decides.
Possible outcomes
- No complaint issues. The matter ends and no criminal case is filed.
- A complaint issues. You are then charged, arraigned, and the case proceeds in district court.
- A continuance or pre-complaint resolution. In some cases the magistrate holds the matter open on conditions, such as paying restitution, staying away from a store, or completing a class, and then ends it.
Why a lawyer helps
The hearing may be your best chance to avoid a criminal record, and what you say there can be used later. A lawyer can review the police report first, decide whether you should speak at all, present mitigating facts, and negotiate with the complainant. In shoplifting and similar cases, an attorney may be able to resolve restitution and ask the magistrate not to issue a complaint.
How to prepare.
- Read the notice for the date, time, and courthouse. Do not ignore it.
- Do not contact the person who made the complaint.
- Gather anything that supports your side, such as receipts, messages, photos, or names of witnesses.
- Dress neatly and arrive early.
Brian Roman has represented clients at clerk magistrate hearings in Attleboro, Taunton, Dedham, Wrentham, Plymouth, and across Massachusetts. If you received a notice, contact (508) 687-6404 for a free consultation before the hearing.